| Settlement Procedures |
Settlements through any of the three main securities depositories listed above are processed in a book-entry environment:
Depository Trust Company The vast majority of broker to broker equity and corporate debt trades clear and settle as pre the following procedures.
TD: The investment manager instructs a broker to initiate a trade in the market. Trades conducted on the exchanges, as well as those that are negotiated outside an exchange and reported to the NSCC by dealers, are transmitted to DTC for settlement. Investment managers send allocations for block trades back to the brokers who then submit a "Notice of Execution" via Omgeo TradeSuite (DTC's trade messaging and settlement services were incorporated into Omgeo TradeSuite in 2001).
T+1: Omgeo TradeSuite adds the transaction(s) to the ID system trade data -base, assigns an id control number and forwards an electronic trade confirmation for each trade to the IM, B-D and IMs custodian. Counterparties view the trade details to affirm the trades and once affirmed, the trades are matched and become irrevocable. Deadline for affirmation is T+1. DTC sets the trade up for automatic settlement on T+1. If either side does not affirm the trade, it is deemed ineligible for Institutional Delivery settlement, and must settle outside of DTC via a separate "Delivery Order". The deadline for institutional trade affirmation at DTCC is 9.00pm on the trade date.
Settlement occurs in DTC by book-entry delivery of securities to the account of the buying customer's custodian bank or broker, against payment to the account of the selling broker or bank. Each DTC settling bank must wire funds to cover its net debit obligation. Likewise, if the settling bank maintains a net credit position at the end of the day, DTC will wire the necessary funds to the settling bank.
Lack of Settlement Finality Settlement in many markets, particularly in Europe, has "finality." Once the delivering party has effected delivery to settle a trade, assuming the main elements of the delivery are correct, the receiving counterparty cannot return the delivery. Confirmations of receipt or delivery are generally regarded as a confirmation of final settlement.
In the US market, there is no finality of settlement. Accordingly, because a delivering or receiving party in the US market cannot guarantee that its delivery or receipt will not be returned or recalled, any related advice, by SWIFT or other means, can be regarded only as confirmation of delivery or receipt. SWIFT acknowledges the lack of settlement finality in the US market and has therefore developed and approved the use of a code in its messaging system.
After settlement has taken place, it is possible for a participant to "DK" a security back to the original delivering party. The recipient of the "DK" (original delivering party) must accept the instruction, thereby crediting their securities account with the DK'd securities and debiting their cash account. Normally, DK does not occur because the trade has not settled through the IDS but the most common reason for a reclaim is failure of the instructing party to provide proper beneficiary account information to the recipient's executing broker.
Federal Reserve System All U.S. treasuries are dematerialised and settle on the Federal Reserve (FRB) book-entry system. Settlement for Treasury securities occurs next day (T+1) unless the counterparties instruct otherwise for same day settlement. Forward settlements may also be negotiated between the counterparties.
The FRB book entry system is a real-time gross settlement system (RTGS). Securities and cash settle on a real-time gross basis. All book-entry movements are immediate and irrevocable, assuming that if there is sufficient position.
On line transfers at the FED take place from 08:30 to 15:00 for free-of-payment (FOP) and delivery vs. payment (DVP) transactions. The deadline for deliveries by Broker Dealers is 15:15, however, in general, market participants should observe 15:00 as the deadline for origination of deliveries of Fedwire eligible securities. The incremental 15 minute settlement period between 15:00 and 15:15 (formerly known as dealer time), will be extended to all parties as an exception process, provided that both parties bilaterally agree.
For DVP deliveries via the FED, the settlement is immediate if there is sufficient position in both accounts (cash and securities) and the custodians FED account is debited with the stock and credited with the cash. If the counterparty rejects the stock, the security and cash movement are reversed. There is a par value limitation of USD50 million on FRB transfers therefore any trades that are greater than USD 50 million par must be split into USD 50 million lots, plus residual, otherwise they will be rejected.
Voluntary fail charges on failing United States (US) Treasury settlements were implemented on May 1, 2009. The fail charge will be 3% less the Fed Funds target rate, or if a Fed Funds target band exists, the fail charge will be 3% less than the lower end of the band. The fails charge will be accrued on each calendar day in the period including the date of the delivery failure, but excluding the date the deliver is eventually settled. The penalty calculation is as follows:
Transaction net cash consideration x (three per cent per annum minus the Fed Funds target rate).
Other Securities Mortgage - Backed Securities (MBS) MBS issues such as FHLMC, GNMA and FNMA settle once a month on a floating schedule, although settlement occurs approximately the same time every month. The issues are divided into one of several "classes" according to agency, maturity, and coupon. Each class settles on a different day, and all securities within that class settle on the same day.
MBS trades can either be specified or generic: in a specified transaction, the exact pools are agreed upon at the time of the trade; if generic pools are used, the seller has until 15:00 on the second business day before settlement to advise the buyer of the exact pools being delivered (the 48 hour rule). If the information required is not communicated as required by the 48 hour rule, delivery cannot be made earlier than two business days after the information is given.
On settlement date, agency MBS are transferred via Fedwire, while private label MBS settle physically between the dealers. The settlement methods for CMO's vary depending on the issuer and whether the securities are DTC eligible. CMO's can either settle physically, at DTC, or at the Federal Reserve.
Futures and Options The clearance and settlement of futures trades is rather complex as a result of daily or twice-daily margin calls. The futures exchanges and their associated clearinghouses handle the settlement and clearing of futures trades. Options are settled and cleared by the Options Clearing Corporation (OCC). Each exchange on which options are traded assumes the responsibility of reconciling trade data and forwarding the data to the OCC who then perform any necessary margin calls. Settlement occurs on the morning of T+1, with same day funds.
Matching Process
There is an affirmation process (DTC-ID) with regard to trade settlement in which the affirming party (broker/IM/custodian) acknowledges that it will settle the trade on settlement date by sending an affirmed confirmation through the system. Trades not affirmed (DTC-Non ID) can be settled by Delivery Orders (DOs). Delivery Orders are used to deliver securities against payment or free to another participant, when either a previously submitted ID confirm has not been affirmed within the specified time-frame, or to make a rapid delivery. A DO is also utilized to "Reclaim" or "DK" a position back to the original sender, if the receiver does not recognize the trade. DOs are processed as and when received by DTC, on a real-time book-entry basis.
Settlement Process
Institutional deliveries of securities within DTC's systems occur through debits and credits to participants' accounts on a gross basis. At the same time, corresponding debits/credits occur to the memorandum cash accounts on the Same Day Funds System (SDFS).
DTC's SDFS system provides significant control features including collateralization of and caps on each participant's intraday net settlement. It allows participants to settle one net money obligation each day, using Fed Funds. Each settling bank monitors its participant's collateral and its net-debit cap. A participant's net debit cap should not exceed its collateral position. If this occurs, all pending receives will queue until sufficient collateral is established. Sufficient collateral can be established by either reclassifying certain securities as "collateral" or by wiring in funds.
Broker-to-Broker Clearing
Broker-to-broker trades are processed and recorded through the National Securities Clearing Corp (NSCC). Details of all trades and legally binding contracts are sent to brokers from the NSCC on T+0 for settlement on T+1. The NSCC acts as central counterparty and its guarantee of trades begins at midnight on T+1, when it reports back to brokers that the trades have been compared. Transactions that fail to match are reported back for corrections. NSCC's instructions remain in force throughout the processing day, so that when securities become available in participant broker accounts, they are utilized for continuous net settlement.
NSCC nets the trades processed by participants to a single cash balance. At the end of the settlement day, a broker will either owe NSCC a net cash obligation or NSCC will owe a broker.
"Cross endorsement" is performed between DTC and NSCC to offset net credit/net debits for brokers with trades involved in both settlement systems. Each participant's net settlement balances are separately summarized, with the final end of day DTC and NSCC balances netted and/or aggregated into one DTC/NSCC balance for each participant.
The vast majority of institutional equity and corporate debt clear and settle in the following manner:
TD: Trade will begin with the institution or the Institutions Investment Manager (IM) placing an order with the Broker-Dealer (B-D). Once the trade is executed (notice of execution) the B-D will advise the IM of the execution details. If it is a block trade the IM will advise the B-D how the trades should be allocated among its accounts. The B-D submits the trade data to Omgeo TradeSuite (DTC's trade messaging and settlement services were incorporated into Omgeo TradeSuite in 2001)
T+1: Omgeo TradeSuite adds the transaction(s) to the ID system trade data -base, assigns an id control number and forwards an electronic trade confirmation for each trade to the IM, B-D and IMs custodian. The IM reviews the confirmation. If the confirmation is accurate the IM or custodian (if they have been assigned to affirm the trade(s) on the IMs behalf) affirms the trade. Omgeo generates an affirmed confirmation and sends it to the B-D/IM and the IMs custodian (if they are affirming on the IMs behalf). At this point the trade is sent to DTCs settlement system and is authorized by the party obligated to deliver the securities for settlement on T+1. If either side does not affirm the trade, it is deemed ineligible for ID settlement, and must settle outside of DTC via a separate "Delivery Order".
Settlement occurs in DTC by book-entry delivery of securities to the account of the buying customer's custodian bank or broker, against payment to the account of the selling broker or bank. During the end of day net settlement process, each DTC participant settles its net cash position with DTC by payment or receipt of a same-day funds wire via the Fed wire system. DTC sends settlement reports to the brokers and custodians identifying the trades that settled on T+1. After settlement has taken place, it is possible for a participant to deliver or "DK" a security back to the original delivering party. The recipient of the "DK" (original delivering party) must accept the instruction, thereby crediting their securities account with the DK'ed securities and debiting their cash memorandum account. Normally, a DK occurs when a security has not been settled through the DTC-ID system, and therefore has not gone through the confirmation/affirmation process.
Government Fixed Income Settlement
All U.S. treasuries are dematerialized and settle on the Federal Reserve (FRB) book-entry system. Settlement for Treasury securities generally occur next day (T+1). However there are times when same day settlement occurs (T+0). Forward settlements may also be negotiated between the counterparties.
The FRB book entry system is a real-time gross settlement system (RTGS). Securities and cash settle on a real-time gross basis. All book-entry movements are immediate, if there is sufficient position, and they are irrevocable. On-line transfers at the FED can take place from 8:30 am to 3:00 pm (ET) for free-of-payment (FOP) and delivery vs. payment (DVP) transactions.
On July 1, 2009 the deadline for deliveries by all market participants was changed to 3:00 PM EST from 3:15 PM EST. The incremental 15 minute settlement period between 3:00 and 3:15 PM EST (formerly known in the market as dealer time) is now extended to all parties, as an exception process, provided both parties to the trade bilaterally agree.
For DVP deliveries via the FED, the settlement is immediate if there is sufficient position in both accounts (cash and securities). The Bank of New York Mellon Asset Servicing's Fed acct is debited with the stock and credited with the cash immediately. If the counterparty rejects the stock, the security and cash movement are reversed.
There is a par value limitation on FRB transfers. Section 10.2.1 of Operating Circular #7 of the Federal Reserve Bank sets a par amount maximum of USD 50 million for transfers ("the limit"). A Reserve Bank will reject a transfer message with a par amount greater than the limit. For the transfer of units greater than USD 50 million par, such trades must be split into USD 50 million lots, plus residual. For example, a trade with a par value of USD 75 million must be split into two separate trades of 50 million and 25 million par. In this situation, many custodians will accept the 75million par trade from the client and will split the trade on their behalf (50million plus 25 million) before sending to the market. Clients should be aware of this limit and should split trades accordingly, if their custodian doesn't offer this service.
Mortgage - Backed Securities (MBS)
Typically, eligible GNMAs, FNMAs and FHLMCs are delivered over the Fedwire.
MBS issues such as FHLMC, GNMA and FNMA settle once a month on a floating schedule, although settlement occurs approximately the same time every month. Settlement dates are announced a year in advance on a rolling 12 month basis. The issues are divided into one of several "classes" according to agency, maturity, and coupon. Each class settles on a different day, with all securities in that class settling on the same day.
MBS trades can either be specified or generic (to be announced (TBA)). In a specified transaction, the exact pools are agreed upon at the time of the trade. If generic pools are used, the seller has until 3:00 pm (ET) on the second business day before settlement to advise the buyer of the exact pools being delivered (the 48 hour rule). If the information is not communicated as required by the 48 hour rule, delivery cannot be made earlier than two business days after the information is given.
On settlement date, agency MBS are transferred via Fedwire, while private label MBS settle physically between the dealers. The settlement methods for CMOs vary depending on the issuer and whether the securities are DTC eligible. CMOs can either settle physically, at DTC, or at the Federal Reserve. Claims Process
The Treasury Markets Practice Group (TMPG) issued a fails charge market practice recommendation in June 2011 (updated in September 2011) for agency debt and agency pass through MBS. This follows on from the fails charge market practice for US Treasuries which was introduced in May 2009. The TMPG believe the practice will preserve and enhance the efficiency and operational integrity of the marketplace for these products by reducing the number of fails. The implementation date for incurring fails charges is February 1, 2011. While the market practice is only a recommendation the expectation is that all industry players will adopt this as a market practice.
For the agency debt market, the TMPG trading practice recommends 1) A settlement fail charge be calculated based on the greater of a) 3 percent minus the federal funds target rate and b) zero. 2) The charge accrues each calendar day a fail is outstanding and is applied with a minimum $500 threshold. Debentures issued by Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the Federal Home Loan Banks are subject to this charge. This is a similar structure to the Treasury Market Fails charge market practice. For the agency pass through MBS market, the TMPG trading practice recommends 1) A settlement fail charge be calculated based on the greater of a) 2 percent minus the federal funds target rate and b) zero. 2) The charge accrues each calendar day a fail is outstanding, although an agency MBS fail is not subject to a charge if delivery occurs on either of the first two business days following contractual settlement date (referred to as the resolution period). On the third business day following settlement date, a charge accruing from contractual settlement date becomes effective. 3) Charges for fails settled in a given calendar month are aggregated between legal entities that are counterparties to one another in a transaction, and a claim is made if aggregate charges for the month exceed $500. Agency MBS issued by or guaranteed by Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae are subject to this charge.
The recommended TMPG fails charge is not applicable in respect of any transaction where delivery is not against the payment of funds or the transfer of securities (i.e. where there is a "free delivery," such as where a party is to deliver or deposit agency debt or agency pass through MBS for margin purposes). The TMPG advised that the charge should not apply to CMOs or other structured securities.
The TMPG recommends the following: 1) That the fails charges apply to transactions in agency debentures and agency MBS entered into on or after February 1, 2012, as well as to transactions that were entered into prior to, but remain unsettled as of, February 1, 2012. 2) For transactions entered into prior to, and unsettled as of, February 1, 2012, the TMPG recommends that the fails charge begin accruing on the later of February 1, 2012, or the contractual settlement date.
For both agency debt and agency MBS claims non-failing parties would provide notice 1) to the failing party of the amounts owed by the 10h business day of the month following the month in which the fail is resolved. 2) Failing parties would make full payment of all fails charges (or reject the claim charges) by the last business day of the month following the month in which the fail is resolved.
Futures and Options
The clearance and settlement of futures trades is rather complex, due to daily or twice-daily margin calls. The futures exchanges and their associated clearinghouses handle the settlement and clearing of futures trades.
Options are settled and cleared by the Options Clearing Corporation (OCC). Each exchange on which options are traded assumes the responsibility of reconciling trade data and forwarding the data to the OCC. The OCC performs any necessary margin calls. Settlement occurs on the morning of T+1, with same day funds.
Physical Securities
Securities held physically in proper negotiable form settle on a T+1 basis. Physical delivery and receipts account for less than 2% of all activity. |
| Clearing Agents |
The National Securities Clearing Corporation (NSCC) is a central counterparty that provides centralised clearance, settlement and information services for virtually all broker-to-broker equity, corporate bond and municipal bond, exchange-traded funds and unit investment trust (UIT) trades in the U.S. It is also the main provider of centralised information services and money settlement for mutual funds and insurance and annuity transactions, linking funds and insurance carriers with their broker/dealer, bank and financial planner distribution channels. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of the DTCC and is the largest of its clearing corporations.
Central Counterparty The National Securities Clearing Corporation (NSCC), established in 1976 provides clearing and settlement, risk management and a completion guarantee for trades involving a variety of instruments, including broker-to-broker equities, corporate and municipal debt, money market instruments, ADRs, ETFs, UITs, mutual funds, and insurance products. It is the largest of the clearing corporations according to transaction volumes and nets trades and payments for participants at the end of the day using the Continuous Net Settlement System. NSCC generally clears and settles trades on a T+1 cycle. The Fixed Income Clearing Corporation (FICC) was created out of a merger between the Government Securities Clearing Corporation (GSCC) and the MBS Clearing Corporation (MBSCC) in January 2003. The Government Securities division of the FICC clears, settles, and nets U.S. Government debt issues, including repos or repurchase agreements. Specifically, it performs multilateral netting and guarantees settlement of all netted trades. The MBS Division of the FICC provides comprehensive netting and settlement services that address the needs of this specialized market. The division offers automated to be announced (TBA) and specified pool trade matching which reduces participants overall settlement obligations.
The Fixed Income Clearing Corporation (FICC) was created out of a merger between the Government Securities Clearing Corporation (GSCC) and the MBS Clearing Corporation (MBSCC) in January 2003. The GSCC clears, settles, and nets U.S. Government Securities transactions, including purchases, sales, and repos of Treasury and Government Agency securities. |
| Depositories |
Depository Trust & Clearing Corp. (DTCC) is the holding company for NSCC, the Depository Trust Company (DTC) and Fixed Income Clearing Corporation (FICC).
FICC was formed by the merger of the Government Securities Clearing Corporation (GSCC) and the MBS Clearing Corporation (MBSCC) FICC is divided into the Government Securities Division and the Mortgage-Backed Securities Division. The Government Securities Division clears, settles and nets a broad range of U.S. Government securities transactions for its 104 member firms (brokers, dealers, banks and other financial institutions) and more than 400 correspondent firms that clear through these members. The Mortgage-Backed Securities Division operates two primary business units: clearing services, which include trade comparison, confirmation, netting, and risk management, and Electronic Pool Notification (EPN) services, which allow customers to transmit/retrieve MBS pool information in real-time as opposed to standardised message formats.
DTC is the depository for most equities, corporate bonds, municipal bonds, local government debt, ADRs and money market instruments.
There are two primary depositories in the U.S.: The Depository Trust Company and the Federal Reserve System. Please refer to the CSD Risk Review for more detailed information on each CSD.
Depository Trust Company
The Depository Trust Company (DTC), established in 1973, was created to reduce costs and provide clearing and settlement efficiencies by immobilizing securities and making "book-entry "changes to ownership of the securities. In 1999, the NSCC, the entity that provides centralized clearing and settlement services for broker-to-broker trades, was merged with DTC to form the Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation (DTCC). DTCC is the holding company for the central depository, the Depository Trust Company (DTC) and it's clearing subsidiaries: the National Securities Clearing Corporation (NSCC) and the Fixed Income Clearing Corporation (FICC). DTCC is owned by its participant banks, broker-dealers, mutual funds firms, and other companies within the financial services industry, such as NASDAQ and the NYSE. DTC is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal Reserve, and the New York State Banking Authority.
DTC provides custody, post-trade processing and a wide range of portfolio servicing. Securities that are eligible for custody and servicing at DTC include, common and preferred stocks, issues of both listed and unlisted corporate debt securities, municipal bonds, certain U.S. Treasury and Federal agency issues, warrants, ADRs, certificates of deposit, some commercial paper, certain mutual funds and closed-end funds, certain global bonds, certain Canadian common and preferred stock and collateralized mortgage obligations. Securities not in Book Entry Only form are immobilized and held in DTC's vaults.
DTC does not act as a Central Registry for the market. Each Member-participant has one or more accounts at DTC in which it holds its own securities or those of its clients. International Links
DTC has international links with the following depositories which facilitate trading in DTC-eligible securities in local markets.
|
Argentina
|
Caja de Valores
|
|
Brazil
|
BM&FBOVESPA
|
|
Canada
|
Canadian Depository for Securities Ltd. (CDS)*
|
|
Chile
|
Deposito Central de Volores (DCV)
|
|
Germany
|
Clearstream Banking*
|
|
Hong Kong
|
Hong Kong Securities Clearing Corp.
|
|
Japan
|
JASDEC
|
|
Israel
|
Tel Aviv Stock Exchange Clearing House (TASE)
|
|
Italy
|
Monte Titoli
|
|
Peru
|
CAVALI ICLV
|
|
Singapore
|
The Central Depository (PTE) Limited
|
|
Switzerland
|
SIX Sega InterSettle (SIS)
|
|
U.K.
|
Crest International Nominees UK*
|
*Two-way Link
Federal Reserve Bank (FRB) is the depository for all government-issued debt and mortgage-backed securities.
Physical Settlement: Physical securities can settle either through DTC physical custody in NY or via physical delivery to the counterparty through the subcustodian bank.
Federal Reserve System The Federal Reserve Book Entry System handles all settlements of U.S. Treasury securities, federal agency securities, treasury bills and re-purchase agreements. The Federal Reserve System provides safekeeping for securities, in both ordinary and pledged accounts. The system also provides repo tracking facilities and offers automated cash adjustment facilities for pooled instruments. In addition, it provides U.S. banks and agencies of foreign banks and domestic depositories with access to its book-entry conversion and wire transfer services (e.g. Fedwire Funds Transfer System).
|
| Registration Process |
Registration: Equity and debt instruments in the U.S. market are generally held in book-entry form with the depository, if eligible.
Book-Entry: Securities held at the DTC are held in the nominee name of the depository, Cede & Co. in the account of the member broker or custodian. All instruments held at the FED are in dematerialised book-entry form and registered in the participant's name.
Depository Eligible – Issues
Depository Trust Company Eligible Issues: Securities, which are eligible for safekeeping at the central depository, Depository Trust Company (DTC) are held in the nominee name of the depository, Cede & Co, in the account of the broker or custodian who is a member of the depository.
Fed Book-Entry Eligible Issues: All instruments held at the Federal Reserve are in dematerialized, book-entry form.
Physical: All physical equity and the majority of long-term debt securities are in registered form. Registered securities must be forwarded to the transfer agent to change the evidence of ownership on the legal records of the issuing company. Under SEC regulations, transfer agents are required to complete re-registration of non-restricted securities within three business days. In practice, however, transfer agents may take longer. Shares are not blocked for trading, but cannot be settled until the registration process has been completed.
Physical Securities
All physical equities are in registered form. Registered securities must be forwarded to the transfer agent to change the evidence of ownership on the legal records of the issuing company. Generally, a transfer agent is a bank or trust company appointed by the issuing corporation. However, some corporations perform this function themselves. Transfer agents are required to complete (turn around) a transfer according to rules set by the SEC. The rules require that most securities be processed for transfer within three business days of receipt, however according to market practice this sometimes takes longer. Transfer agents must also keep records of the number and timeliness of transactions processed for at least two years.
Securities are normally registered in the name of the owner or a nominee. Nominee registrations are commonly used by banks, trust companies, clearing houses, brokers, mutual funds and their financial institutions to minimize re-registration of securities and speed the delivery and settlement process. By holding securities in nominee name (for example, Hare & Co., one of Bank of New York Mellon Asset Servicing's nominees) the bank or fiduciary can readily satisfy delivery requirements by having an authorized officer of that nominee endorse the securities. If it is in nominee name, the nominee will receive all income and corporate action notifications and forward to the beneficial owner.
Transfer fees for physical securities vary by agent and by issue. |